Columbus Crew and New York City have met 6 times. Columbus Crew hold the edge with 3 wins to 2, with 1 drawn. It's a record that frames Columbus Crew as the historical favourite in this fixture, though recent form can shift the picture.
Across those meetings the two have combined for 18 goals — an average of 3.0 per game, marking this out as a high-scoring, open fixture. Columbus Crew have scored 9, New York City 9.
Their most recent meeting (May 20, 2026) finished Columbus Crew 1–0 New York City in the US Open Cup.
They have met 6 times: 3 Columbus Crew wins, 1 draws and 2 New York City wins.
Columbus Crew have the better head-to-head record, with 3 wins to 2.
Columbus Crew 1–0 New York City, in the US Open Cup.