Cincinnati and Columbus Crew have met 6 times, and the rivalry is remarkably even: 2 wins each way is no exaggeration, with 2 of those games drawn. Neither side can claim a clear historical edge.
Across those meetings the two have combined for 16 goals — an average of 2.7 per game, marking this out as a balanced fixture for goals. Cincinnati have scored 10, Columbus Crew 6.
Their most recent meeting (November 08, 2025) finished Cincinnati 2–1 Columbus Crew in the USA. MLS (Play-off).
They have met 6 times: 2 Cincinnati wins, 2 draws and 2 Columbus Crew wins.
Cincinnati 2–1 Columbus Crew, in the USA. MLS (Play-off).