New York Red Bulls and St. Louis City have met 3 times, and the rivalry is remarkably even: 1 wins each way is no exaggeration, with 1 of those games drawn. Neither side can claim a clear historical edge.
Across those meetings the two have combined for 9 goals — an average of 3.0 per game, marking this out as a high-scoring, open fixture. New York Red Bulls have scored 5, St. Louis City 4.
Their most recent meeting (January 24, 2026) finished New York Red Bulls 3–1 St. Louis City in the Club Friendlies.
They have met 3 times: 1 New York Red Bulls wins, 1 draws and 1 St. Louis City wins.
New York Red Bulls 3–1 St. Louis City, in the Club Friendlies.